I've stumbled across some new information about our family history, and I thought you might be interested. Here's the story: When I first started with genealogy, I hit a brick wall right away with the McDowell line. The first few generations (starting with Grandad) were easy. We have Grandad’s birth certificate that says his father was Samuel Thompson McDowell.
Here’s where things got frustrating. There are several McDowell family lines documented on the internet, and many of them claim our Samuel McDowell. 
That’s where my records sat for around 20 years. I would occasionally look around for new information, and I even contributed some saliva for family DNA analysis to see if that would lead anywhere. The next step remained unsettled, though.
And then, earlier this month, a fellow from the McDowell Project at Family Tree DNA (which has been saving my saliva all this time) e-mailed me to see if I was interested in having more DNA markers evaluated. This project, he said, was interested in having the more extensive analysis done for someone from our line. I told him that I was interested but warned him that our line was not as well documented as he seemed to think.
“BOOM”, he said (not really), and gave me three documents that definitively show that Richard Cook’s genealogy was right all along. These documents are real estate records. The first step comes from a real estate transaction that occurred after the death of John McDowell of Adair County, Kentucky (the John mentioned above). His survivors included his wife Phebe, their children, and their children's spouses. Here’s the text (click this link for an image of the document; look on the right side):
John, as it turns out, was a veteran of the War of 1812 and some unspecified “Indian War”. At some point, Phebe must have learned that this service entitled him to a land grant, and she applied for the grant as his widow. The text of the grant reads “Phebe McDowell, widow of John McDowell deceased, Private in Captain Wood’s Company, Kentucky Militia (two services) Indian and War 1812.” The land was located in southwestern Illinois. (Click this link for an image of the document).
So far, this still doesn’t help us. We need something that links the Samuel McDowell on the first document to our Samuel in Iowa. That comes with a transaction that occurred after Phebe’s death. When she died, George, Elizabeth, and Samuel each inherited an “interest” of the Illinois land. George, who lived in Illinois at this point, paid $50 each to Elizabeth and Samuel, buying them out:
Pg 2 (image)
executors and administrators, shall and will warrant and defend the title to the premises to the said party of the second part, and to his heirs and assigns forever, against the lawful claims of all persons whatsoever. In witness whereof, the said party of the first part hath hereunto set her hand and seal, the day and year first above written. Executed in presence of Elizabeth Boley (Seal) State of Missouri County of Carroll Be it remembered, that on this Twentieth day of October, A.D. Eighteen hundred and fifty Seven, before me the undersigned Clerk of the Circuit Court of Carroll County, came Elizabeth Boley, who is personally known to me to be the same person whose name is subscribed to the foregoing instrument of writing, as part thereto, and she acknowledged the same to be her act and deed for the purposes therein mentioned. In testimony whereof, I Overton J. Kirby, Clerk as aforesaid, have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of said Court at office, the day & year last aforesaid. Recorded August 2nd, 1858. Overton J. Kirby Clk. by
Pg 3 (image)
in and for said County, do certify, that Charles Johnson, now, who was on the 21st day of May, A.D. 1858, an acting Justice of the Peace of Macoupin County, State of Illinois, duly elected, commissioned and qualified, that his signature to the fore- going acknowledgement is genuine, and that full faith and credit is and ought to be given to his official acts as such Justice of the Peace. Witness, Enoch Wall, Clerk of the County Court of said County, and the seal thereof, at his office in Carlinville this 21 day of May, A.D. 1858. Enoch Wall, Clerk. Recorded August 2nd, 1858. Robert W. Davis, Clerk.
[Samuel/Perlina transaction]
For the consideration of the sum of Fifty Dollars, We hereby convey to George McDowell all our right, title and interest in and to the following described Real Estate, situated in the County of Montgomery in the State of Illinois, to wit: The North East quarter of the South West quarter of section seventeen (17) in township no ten (10) north of Range no one (1) west. And we warrant the title to the same against the lawful claims of all persons holding by through or under us. In Witness Whereof we have hereunto have hereunto subscribed our names this seventh day of June A.D. 1858.
Pg4 (image)
Saml Mc Dowell (Seal)
Perlina Mc Dowell (Seal)
State of Iowa,
Decatur County Before me Thomas Pitman a Justice of the Peace in and for said County and State aforesaid personally appeared Samuel Mc Dowell and Perlina Mc Dowel his wife, personally known to me to be the identical persons whose names are subscribed to the above deed of conveyance as grantors, and acknowledged the signing thereof to be their voluntary act and deed, this 7th day of June A.D. 1858. Thomas Pitman Justice of the Peace. State of Iowa, Decatur County S.S. I George F. Young Clerk of the district Court of Decatur County Iowa. do hereby certify, that Thomas Pitman before whom the foregoing acknowledgement was made and whose genuine signature is hereto attached and was at the time of taking the same, a Legal acting Justice of the Peace, in and for said County, Iowa, and that all his official acts as such justice are entitled to full faith and credit.
(Another aside: the handwriting in these images are clerks' transcriptions into the Illinois records from the original documents. There are no original signatures in these images. The little squiggly line next to some of the names are the clerk's documentation that there was a signature on the original. If you look closely, you can see where they wrote "SEAL" in the scribble.)
And there you have it… the Samuel McDowell in Decatur County, Iowa, sold his interest in the Illinois land granted to the wife of John McDowell from Adair County, Kentucky. This establishes the link between the KY Samuel and the IA Samuel.
This breaks things wide open. The online story is remarkably consistent from here on; other people generally accept Cook’s story, and Frank Bouley has cleaned it up and added to it in his version. There’s some great material in the Bouley version. If you're interested at all in McDowell history, this is a great place to start.
Here are some pdfs that document the generations through the McDowell line (includes notes, obituaries, etc. for more recent generations):
Ephraim McDowel & Margaret Adams
Ephraim McDowell & Elizabeth Burns
John McDowell & Phebe Franklin
Samuel McDowell & Perlina Elmore
Samuel Thompson McDowell & Margarette Massey
The guy at the McDowell Project at Family Tree DNA is hoping that the more extensive analysis of the DNA I provided will push back things even further. (Those results will be available in early 2027.) He thinks that our first Ephraim was the son of one of four brothers who came to America together.
This has been focusing on the men because I’ve been following the McDowell name. I also have a lot of information on the various maternal lines. Click these images to enlarge and see the big picture.
If you’re interested in digging into this, I’d recommend getting some family tree software (I use an old version of Family Historian). I can provide a file you can import so you don't have to enter everything by hand.
Please share this info with anyone who might be interested; the more people who have it, the less likely it will be lost. Definitely let me know if you see something that's wrong or just doesn't hang together with other info. I don’t know how long I’ll keep this web page active. I’m hosting it on my music server which is running out of space. I won’t take it down any time soon, but it won’t be up forever. Please print or save any documents you’d like to keep.
Brad
November 2026